Store Nostalgic Candy Store / Nostalgic Candy Sort by We recommend Newest arrivals Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Name: A to Z Name: Z to A Beemans Gum $0.99 Beemans Gum Candy Filled Fruit $0.59 Candy Filled Fruit Bit-o-honey bag $3.19 Bit-o-honey bag Bottle Caps $2.49 Bottle Caps Caramel Apple Pop $0.69 Caramel Apple Pop Charms rolls $2.39 Charms rolls Abba Zaba Bar $2.39 Abba Zaba Bar Big Hunk $2.39 Big Hunk Black Jack Gum $0.99 Black Jack Gum Candy Cigarettes $1.99 Candy Cigarettes Cherry Mash $2.99 Cherry Mash Cinnamon Cube Pop $0.99 Cinnamon Cube Pop Cow Tales Caramel Apple $0.69 Cow Tales Caramel Apple Cow Tales Chocolate $0.69 Cow Tales Chocolate Cow Tales-Straw $0.69 Cow Tales-Straw Cow Tales Vanilla $0.69 Cow Tales Vanilla Fun Dip 3 flavor $2.49 Fun Dip 3 flavor Bubble Gum Cigarettes $1.99 Bubble Gum Cigarettes Candy Buttons $1.99 Candy Buttons Clove Gum $0.99 Clove Gum Gold Mine Gum $2.49 Gold Mine Gum Goodart's Peanut Pattie $1.99 Goodart's Peanut Pattie Hot Lix Cinn Toothpix $1.99 Hot Lix Cinn Toothpix Hot Lix Mint Toothpix $1.99 Hot Lix Mint Toothpix lifesavers butter rum $2.09 lifesavers butter rum Look dark chocolate $2.49 Look dark chocolate McGraws Giant Taffy $1.99 McGraws Giant Taffy Moon Pie - Banana $1.49 Moon Pie - Banana Moon Pies - Salted Caramel $1.49 Moon Pies - Salted Caramel Moon Pies - Salted Caramel $1.49 Moon Pies - Salted Caramel Moon Pie - Vanilla $1.49 Moon Pie - Vanilla Neapolitan Coconut Bar $2.49 Neapolitan Coconut Bar Nik-l-Nip 8pk $3.49 Nik-l-Nip 8pk Claeys - Old Fashioned Peppermint $3.19 Claeys - Old Fashioned Peppermint Razzles $2.49 Razzles Reeds Butterscotch $2.09 Reeds Butterscotch reeds peppermint $2.09 reeds peppermint reed's peppermint $1.76 reed's peppermint Reeds Root Beer $2.09 Reeds Root Beer Stick Candy - Birthday Cake $0.50 Stick Candy - Birthday Cake Stick Candy - Blueberry $0.50 Stick Candy - Blueberry Stick Candy - Butterscotch $0.50 Stick Candy - Butterscotch Stick Candy - Cherry $0.50 Stick Candy - Cherry Stick Candy - Cinnamon $0.50 Stick Candy - Cinnamon Stick Candy - Cotton Candy $0.50 Stick Candy - Cotton Candy Stick Candy - Grape - D $0.50 Stick Candy - Grape - D Stick Candy - Raspberry $0.50 Stick Candy - Raspberry Stick Candy - Root Beer $0.50 Stick Candy - Root Beer Stick Candy - Sour Apple $0.50 Stick Candy - Sour Apple Stick Candy - tutti frutti $0.50 Stick Candy - tutti frutti Sugar Daddy Pop $2.49 Sugar Daddy Pop Sweeteart roll $2.49 Sweeteart roll Zagnut $2.59 Zagnut Zero Bar (hersheys) $2.59 Zero Bar (hersheys) Zotz Cherry Apple Watermelon $0.99 Zotz Cherry Apple Watermelon Zotzs - Blue Raspberry Orange Grape $0.99 Zotzs - Blue Raspberry Orange Grape
